Prescription pills spilled abundantly over 20 dollar bills, highlighting how access to healthcare necessities is dictated by one’s income background. Photo courtesy of ccPixs.com.
Every year, millions of low-income young Americans lose comprehensive healthcare under Medicaid after their 19th birthdays, without an affordable alternative; meanwhile, most other young adults remain on their parents’ insurance until age 26. America’s two-tiered healthcare system sets young adults on separate tracks that shape the remainder of their lives. Young adults between 19 and 26 from households with private insurance, defined here as “high-income,” can “follow their dreams” with greater flexibility. They are encouraged to experiment and make “mistakes” —acts that deviate from a traditional employment pipeline pursued with confidence—for the first half of their twenties without being as constrained by their basic healthcare needs. For “low-income” individuals, the same mistakes could carry significant consequences for their health. Moreover, the stress of avoiding mistakes frequently takes a toll on their health, placing more stress on the healthcare system.
Individuals on Medicaid face a self-calculated serfdom—they must remain consistently employed, but earn too little to get by. Living paycheck-to-paycheck, they cannot plan beyond immediate expenses like rent, bills, and groceries or build emergency or retirement funds.
This raises the question of how beneficial the system truly is. Adults who qualify for Medicaid based on household income can only earn up to 138% of the federal poverty level. Rigid adult Medicaid requirements and stricter work requirements coming into effect in January 2027 trap young Americans in a system that limits opportunities for upward mobility and the pursuit of their passions.
The Social Security Act provides that Medicaid and CHIP coverage under the children’s guidelines end at age 19, so those who wish to retain Medicaid must meet adult Medicaid eligibility requirements within their state. This age limit differs substantially from that of a parent’s private insurance plan, as the Affordable Care Act—the same act that set the upper age limit for qualifying for childhood Medicaid—mandates that dependents on both employer-sponsored plans and Marketplace plans can stay on their parents’ insurance until age 26.
According to a University of Chicago study, 35.6% of young adults without medically complex conditions lost Medicaid coverage after turning nineteen, while 13% of young adults with chronic and/or complex medical conditions, including heart disease or cystic fibrosis, also lost their coverage. As most of these individuals still come from low-income households, losing Medicaid coverage may leave them without an affordable alternative and increase their financial insecurity.
Instead of addressing these coverage gaps, Congress has enacted additional eligibility requirements that may further reduce Medicaid enrollment. Even young adults who remain eligible under Medicaid expansion criteria may face additional barriers to maintaining coverage. With the federal work requirements for some adults on Medicaid set to take effect on January 1st, 2027, more young adults may lose coverage due to work requirements, more frequent eligibility checks, or difficulties documenting exemptions.
Under Section 71119 of the One Big Beautiful Bill Act (OBBBA), adults ages 19-64 who are members of the Medicaid expansion population and do not qualify for a statutory exemption must engage in “community engagement” for at least 80 hours per month. To meet this requirement, they must “work at least 80 hours”, “complete at least 80 hours of community service”, “be enrolled at least half-time in an educational program”, or satisfy one of the limited alternative pathways under the statute.
These requirements leave little room for nuance or nontraditional employment arrangements, as individuals who do not follow a traditional work schedule must demonstrate a monthly income “that is at least as much as the equivalent of minimum wage multiplied by 80 hours.” At the $7.25 federal minimum wage, individuals who rely on earnings to satisfy this requirement must earn at least $580 per month to meet this threshold; yet, they cannot exceed the income threshold for Medicaid eligibility—generally 138% of the federal poverty level for adults in Medicaid expansion states. In states with a $15 minimum wage, this could constrain adults to earn between $1,200 and $1,865 per month to satisfy the work requirement without exceeding the Medicaid eligibility threshold.
While their peers age out of compulsory education and gain greater autonomy over their time, low-income individuals on Medicaid must walk a tightrope to maintain coverage. Moreover, many are already doing so without a federal mandate: 64% of adults on Medicaid under 65 are already working, and an additional 28% who aren’t employed are enrolled in education programs, caregiving, or disabled.
Despite this, Subchapter D of the Medicaid chapter of the OBBBA is entitled “Increasing Personal Accountability”, framing Medicaid eligibility as an issue of individual responsibility and employment. This approach overlooks the varied reasons individuals might be unemployed, as well as the steps they may take to find employment outside a rigidly defined schedule.
The rhetoric used to justify restrictions on Medicaid rests on two seemingly contradictory concepts: “empowering” adults to work again, and “punishing” the “Welfare Queens” who “misuse” government resources. This rhetoric distracts the American public from questioning why they must pay into insurance companies while dozens of countries offer free coverage to their citizens, instead directing societal blame toward those who “unfairly” receive coverage without paying “like the rest of us”. This strict employment mandate frames losing a job and struggling to find a new one as a moral failing, justifying systematically robbing individuals of their health.
This requirement creates a class of low-wage workers who cannot afford to leave their positions. As the American Dream is perpetuated across the country, an individual’s ability to create a better life measures their success, regardless of external challenges. Young adults expected to exercise “personal accountability,” “pull themselves up by their bootstraps,” and pursue their chosen careers may now find themselves constrained by rigid requirements and the risks of leaving temporary positions that allow them to maintain coverage.
The seven-year disparity between age limits for Medicaid coverage and remaining on a parent’s private insurance cannot be overstated. A person’s late teens and early twenties are a vital period of self-discovery. After high school graduation, young adults gain greater autonomy over their time and commitments. They can choose opportunities based on their own means; in practice, however, external pressures often constrain the choices they believe they can make.
The years between the ages 19 and 26 are a time when many young people mature, develop autonomy, and may change their minds. Young people will inevitably make mistakes. Any healthcare system should give its users the opportunity to live without trading work for their health. Young people who aren’t yet concerned with insurance can take an unpaid internship for personal or career development, leave an unaffordable education program, take a gap year, or quit a job to reevaluate their goals. Those who age off of their parents’ Medicaid coverage, however, don’t have the luxury of mistakes. As they approach their nineteenth birthday, they’re expected to have a plan to maintain Medicaid.
Even within the same economic class, the American household is never one-size-fits-all. Whatever the reason a family qualifies for Medicaid, parents may be able to adapt so their children—who may have worked or contributed at home disproportionately to higher-income peers—can pursue opportunities on their own timeline. The expectation of regularly tracked hours as the price for healthcare, however, strips away their ability to plan for the future, take time to figure things out, or leave their current situation.Without the ability to take chances, they face a higher likelihood of repeating the cycle of poverty.
While regular work at-or-above the minimum wage may appear to improve the financial stability of these disadvantaged young adults, policymakers should exercise caution when exerting policies that impact individuals’ free will and the circumstances of affected populations. The ceiling on childhood Medicaid coverage disregards economic disparities between Medicaid and privately insured recipients, and the Medicaid work requirements neglect the varied circumstances of low-income households. By imposing sweeping economic legislation that dictates how one must spend their time, affected individuals are not seen as individuals, but as a monolithic drain on government spending.
A rise in employment may be considered a marker of success, but feels like a bandage to distract from the socioeconomic factors that lead an individual to rely on Medicaid in the first place. As the bill fails to account for the numerous individuals on Medicaid who are already employed or unemployed for an exempt reason, its stringency seems designed less to assist individuals in getting back on their feet, and more so to cut government spending at all costs—even when those costs are the health, freedom, and livelihoods of Americans.
Eden Leskovac (BC '30) is a Staff Writer at CPR studying architecture, urban studies, and human rights. Eden has a particular interest in using communications and storytelling as vessels for critique within film, art, and writing. Other styles of written work have been published in the Ralph Munn Creative Writing Anthology and the Kenyon Young Writers Anthology. Eden can be reached at eml2258@barnard.edu.
