Alphas in the Armed Forces

 

Pete Hegseth’s flexed arm while speaking with attendees at the 2021 Student Action Summit hosted by Turning Point USA at the Tampa Convention Center in Tampa, Florida. Photo courtesy of Gage Skidmore.

 

Words matter. If you don’t believe me, then believe Secretary Pete Hegseth. He claims that the Department of Defense “[hasn’t] won a war” since World War II, and for a very simple reason: In 1947, the victorious War Department renamed itself the Department of Defense. To right that wrong, President Donald Trump has changed the name yet again, this time to something notably more aggressive: The Department of War. Hegseth concurred, “[T]his name change is not just about renaming, it's about restoring; words matter.”

This back-and-forth isn’t just posturing to the MAGA base or making Hegseth feel like a big, tough guy (well, maybe a little bit). It’s reflective of a deeper trend in the second Trump administration. MAGA doesn't just want to reshape how the government works, but also how we view it. The “Department of War” doesn’t seek to restore a historically more successful American military (if it did, Trump would have given the institution its original name: The War Department). Instead, the institution was renamed to break with the tradition cultivated since World War II. Renaming is an act of destruction as much as it is one of creation, wiping away the past and ushering in the new.

Recreating an institution as fundamental to American society as the military is no easy task. Even members of Trump’s party opposed dramatic moves to politicize the armed forces. But it has become a central goal of Hegseth, with a mandate granted by Trump. Focusing on the semantics of this recreation reveals their deeper intentions: to transform the nonpartisan profession of arms into a militarized arm of the broader MAGA movement.

None of these changes are possible without the language that goes along with it. MAGA, despite being supposedly obsessed with tradition, is surprisingly novel with its language. This rhetorical skill castigates enemies within the military as “woke” to justify their removal. Hegseth’s tenure has led to one of the most significant purges of the top brass in US history, replacing them with ideological loyalists. Here, another break with the past is created.

One particularity of this changing language is the arrival of the warfighter and the warrior ethos. Although not solely a novelization of the MAGA movement, these terms have exploded in popularity under Hegseth’s tutelage, replacing the less aggressive “servicemember” as a catch-all for the US’ soldiers, sailors, marines, airmen, coast guardsmen, national guardsmen, and guardians. Breaking down this change is emblematic of a new self-perception Hegseth wants to encourage: Servicemembers are subservient, they serve. Now, they are warriors who fight. The very nature of the occupation has fundamentally changed, as the Department of War challenges its need to “serve” the Constitution.

But it’s not enough to be a warfighter, a warrior, or anti-woke. The newest push, in a page taken straight out of an incel manifesto, is to cultivate alphas in the armed forces. Hegseth has rolled out a shocking new program designed to boost troops’ testosterone. While he previously worked tirelessly to kick transgender servicemembers out of the armed forces, the Secretary is now proselytizing his warfighters to get on hormones.

Purging the officer corps and refusing to promote officers who don’t fit Hegseth’s imagined ideal candidate (a straight white cissexual tough guy—just like the Secretary himself!) has made room for MAGA’s preferred candidates to rise. This includes officers preaching to their troops that the ongoing war with Iran is part of “God’s divine plan” to bring about Armageddon. These Christian nationalist ideas have been given the green light to spread among the ranks, encouraged by the Secretary and by officers who, in the now extinct Department of Defense, would have been appropriately reprimanded for such a clear violation of the Uniform Code of Military Justice, the body of laws that govern the legal behavior of those serving in uniform.

For a movement so adamant on portraying itself as tough, MAGA is surprisingly sensitive. Experienced leaders who say the wrong things get the boot. People who don’t fit Hegseth’s vision for a military, like women and queer people, get the boot. In an extreme example, during my time in the US Air Force, I was forced to remove pronouns from my email signature. While my leadership didn’t threaten me to do so, the message was clear from the top. Words matter.

Ultimately, these purges and reforms don’t actually create a more “lethal” military force. There are plenty of real issues that need to be addressed within the Pentagon. Decades of bloat and financial mismanagement have weakened the capabilities of the force far more than the introduction of pronouns in emails ever could. But that’s not really what matters; what matters is institutional capture. While the Department of War is fighting wars abroad, often on dubious standing, its primary target remains clear: Blue America.

In this way, Hegseth is engaging his Department of War in daily combat with an enemy more “dangerous” than any others: Democrats, communists, and transgenders. The administration’s rhetoric surrounding these groups continues to heat up. Trump is adding fuel to the fire, blaming “radical left cities” for provoking a “war from within.”

That war is being fought unconstitutionally and without precedent. Using the military for retributive political ends is unusual in American history, and Trump’s decision to deploy National Guard units for political optics against his enemies is impacting the military’s public perception. For a long time, the armed forces enjoyed the top spot as the country’s most trusted institution. Since Hegseth has taken over, public support has declined to a twenty-year low.

The increasingly militarized language supports a partisan, ideological, and nonrepresentative military. Already, the military is becoming less “national” as volunteers come from a smaller selection of military families. This pseudo-military caste is becoming more distant from the average American. By shaping the military in a distinctly MAGA direction, we are witnessing one of the US’ most lauded institutions become corrupted by unpopular extremists.

As long as the real problems go unaddressed, and the nonpartisan professionals who seek to tackle these problems continue to be targeted and dismissed, then the US military will become weaker, more insular, and less adherent to the democratic spirit from which it arose. 


Jay Jacobson (GS ’28) is a Policy 360 staff writer comfortably at home in New York City, majoring in Political Science and Slavic Studies. They can be reached at jj3566@columbia.edu.

 
Previous
Previous

They’re Trying to Make You Crazy

Next
Next

What Effective Altruism Got Wrong — and What It Got Right